Seeking Technical Insight
Imagine you are representing a client who was injured in a serious car accident. You would certainly hire automobile and forensic experts to help you investigate all the pertinent crash details to recreate the moments leading up to and immediately after the crash. From the velocity of the car at impact to the approach angle, whether brakes were applied or if the driver was impaired, all these details and more are critical to conveying the life-changing impact of the accident to the jury.
Now, consider that in nearly every modern medical malpractice case, you have a silent observer continuously noting details about every user’s interaction with a patient’s medical record: an electronic medical record (EMR) system. For the plaintiff, it may produce evidence to support their complaint. For the defendant, it may produce evidence to support the care provided. Could you tease out crucial details from an EMR system, develop a technical timeline of events, and accurately interpret the data of the EMR system objectively?
Simply recreating an accurate timeline in a medical malpractice case often requires expert insight and experience in designing, developing, using, and reviewing EMR systems and audit logs. Additional expertise is required if questions arise about the meaning, completeness, accuracy, and timeliness, or ways that the EMR system’s user interface or automated clinical decision support tools may have contributed to alleged events.
Schedule Your Free Case Consultation
See Our CalendarWhere to Find EMR Expert Witnesses
Identifying well-qualified EMR expert witnesses to aid a legal team can be challenging. Often times, tech-savvy medical or nursing expert witnesses offer EMR related services
EMR expert witness candidates often come from the field of healthcare technology or clinical informatics, which studies the design, development, implementation, use, and evaluation of information in EMR systems. They may have degrees or educational experiences in clinical informatics, software design, or database engineering.
Additionally, an EMR expert witness candidate typically has worked for EMR vendors or health systems and has expertise in healthcare system administration, health law and policy, computer science, medical billing, medical record review, information technology, and/or healthcare compliance.
Furthermore, an EMR expert witness candidate may be associated with a health information industry organization such as the American Health Information Management Association (AHIMA), the Healthcare Information Management Systems Society (HIMSS), the Healthcare Business Management Association (HBMA), or many others that exist in the healthcae technology industry.
Choose Right, Ensure Relevance
EMR expert witness services may include report preparation, computer forensics, expert opinion, deposition testimony, and courtroom testimony. They are often called upon to educate the court on details about electronic evidence and often work alongside a clinician or medical expert to support a case. In some cases, one EMR expert witness may not provide a legal team with all the insights needed for a case, such as cases involving multiple EMR systems. Building a strong EMR expert witness team for a case can enable attorneys to deliver great value to their clients in reaching a desired outcome.
One important characteristic in selecting an EMR expert witness include matching their professional background to the needs of the case. An expert who has decades of experience in one EMR system may not perform well in a case involving a different EMR system. Another key characteristic is the type of EMR experiences the EMR expert witness
Examples of litigation support matters requiring an EMR expert witness include medical malpractice cases, intellectual property, false claims, and health insurance fraud. An expert witness must not only have the appropriate substantive expertise but should also possess the ability to explain the facts of the case to a judge and jury while having credentials such as EMR vendor certifications and/or years of IT analyst or configuration experience in the defendant’s system.
Not All EMR Expert Witnesses Are Equal
As attorneys decide whether to implement EMR expert witnesses, it is important to qualify who they retain and whether they truly will add value to their case.
A noted Medicare fraud damages expert assisted an attorney in a successful outcome before the U.S. Court of Appeals in 2021. The expert was regarded as one of the best expert witnesses in their field and cited their careful analysis of EMR systems and paper records that helped the defense win the case. However, expert witness testimony can potentially undermine a case. Recognizing problems that are commonly associated with EMR expert witness testimony and how to get around them can help lawyers better prepare cases for court.
An EMR expert witness’s qualifications may be challenged if they cannot demonstrate experience or education to support their opinions in a case. If an EMR expert witness appears to be shaping their opinion based on their attorney-client’s case theory, without supportive evidence from the EMR, the jury may not find the expert credible. Another potential problem is that the expert did not adequately perform their analyses or identify a clear methodology in their report. They may even provide testimony that agrees with the other side of the case. If an expert provides an opinion that is based on incorrect or incomplete facts, they can quickly lose credibility with the jury. Any of these examples can cause major issues for an attorney during a deposition or trial.
